What changed between revision 1 and revision 2, compared over the article's markdown source with its frontmatter — so a change to status, evidence or reversibility shows up as the edit it is.
Older · revision 1
Import· initial corpus import, not an edit
Initial import of content/artificial-neurons.md — the filesystem corpus, unchanged. Not an edit.
15.6 kB
Revision 1
Revision 2
lines 8–14 → 8–147 unchanged lines not shown
categories: ["cybernetics"]categories: ["cybernetics"]tags: ["neuromorphic", "memristors", "organic electronics", "bioelectronics", "neural interface", "neuroprosthetics"]tags: ["neuromorphic", "memristors", "organic electronics", "bioelectronics", "neural interface", "neuroprosthetics"]summary: "Physical electronic devices that generate neuron-like spikes at biological voltages and timescales so they can exchange signals directly with living nerve cells and tissue."summary: "Physical electronic devices that generate neuron-like spikes at biological voltages and timescales so they can exchange signals directly with living nerve cells and tissue."updated: "2026-10-27"updated: "2026-10-29"humanEvidence: "No human study has been run; every coupling to living tissue has been acute, in mouse brain slices, cultured rat neurons, stem-cell-derived heart cells in a dish, or the vagus nerve of anaesthetized mice."humanEvidence: "No human study has been run; every coupling to living tissue has been acute, in mouse brain slices, cultured rat neurons, stem-cell-derived heart cells in a dish, or the vagus nerve of anaesthetized mice."access: "Nothing to obtain: these are laboratory prototypes with no approved device, no commercial product, and no reported human trial."access: "Nothing to obtain: these are laboratory prototypes with no approved device, no commercial product, and no reported human trial."reversibility: "difficult"reversibility: "difficult"lines 42–50 → 42–5027 unchanged lines not shown
"Artificial neuron" names three different things, and news coverage regularly blurs them."Artificial neuron" names three different things, and news coverage regularly blurs them. The oldest is mathematical. The units of a software neural network, descended from theThe oldest is mathematical. The units of a software neural network, descended from theMcCulloch–Pitts model of 1943, are weighted sums passed through a nonlinearity. They have noMcCulloch-Pitts model of 1943, are weighted sums passed through a nonlinearity. They have nophysical form and no electrical contact with anything biological, and they are what the phrasephysical form and no electrical contact with anything biological, and they are what the phrase meansmeans in machine learning and in debates about [[artificial-general-intelligence]].in machine learning and in debates about [[artificial-general-intelligence]]. The second is neuromorphic hardware: circuits that emulate spiking neurons physically, mostly toThe second is neuromorphic hardware: circuits that emulate spiking neurons physically, mostly tocompute more efficiently. Mahowald and Douglas built an analog "silicon neuron" in 1991 thatcompute more efficiently. Mahowald and Douglas built an analog "silicon neuron" in 1991 thatlines 52–62 → 52–621 unchanged line not shown
hardware since then has been designed for computing rather than for contact with tissue, and mosthardware since then has been designed for computing rather than for contact with tissue, and mostartificial neurons have operated at signal amplitudes of half a volt or more.[^fu2025]artificial neurons have operated at signal amplitudes of half a volt or more.[^fu2025] The third, the subject here, is the bio-interfacing subset: devices whose purpose is to sit in orThe third, the subject here, is the bio-interfacing subset: devices built to sit in or next tonext to living tissue and exchange signals with it. That imposes requirements computing does not.living tissue and exchange signals with it. That imposes requirements that computing does not.Biological action potentials are on the order of 100 millivolts and last about a millisecond; theBiological action potentials are on the order of 100 millivolts and last about a millisecond, thedevice must work in salty, wet surroundings; and, ideally, it responds to the chemical signalsdevice must work in salty, wet surroundings, and ideally it responds to the chemical signals neuronsneurons use as well as the electrical ones.use as well as the electrical ones. ## How it works## How it works lines 65–93 → 65–932 unchanged lines not shown
**Analog silicon neurons** model each ion channel with a transistor circuit. A University of Bath**Analog silicon neurons** model each ion channel with a transistor circuit. A University of Bathteam fitted conductance models to recordings from rat hippocampal and brainstem respiratory neuronsteam fitted conductance models to recordings from rat hippocampal and brainstem respiratory neuronsand used the fitted parameters to configure silicon neurons, which responded nearly identically toand used the fitted parameters to configure silicon neurons, which responded nearly identically tothe biological cells; the completed models matched recorded membrane voltage with 94–97% agreementthe biological cells. The completed models matched recorded membrane voltage with 94-97% agreementacross 60 current-injection protocols.[^abuhassan2019] The authors propose such circuits as aacross 60 current-injection protocols.[^abuhassan2019] The authors propose such circuits as a routeroute to implants that repair failing neural circuits; the study itself compared chip and neuronto implants that repair failing neural circuits, but the study itself compared chip and neuronoffline and connected nothing to tissue.offline and connected nothing to tissue. **Memristive neurons** use a component whose resistance switches abruptly when a conductive filament**Memristive neurons** use a component whose resistance switches abruptly when a conductive filamentforms and then dissolves, producing a spike in a simple circuit. The difficulty has been that mostforms and then dissolves, producing a spike in a simple circuit. The difficulty has been that mostfilamentary memristors switch above half a volt, several times the amplitude of a biological spike.filamentary memristors switch above half a volt, several times the amplitude of a biological spike.A University of Massachusetts Amherst group used protein nanowires harvested from the bacterium *GeobacterA University of Massachusetts Amherst group used protein nanowires harvested from the bacteriumsulfurreducens* to build memristors that switch at about 60 millivolts and 1.7 nanoamps, with a*Geobacter sulfurreducens* to build memristors that switch at about 60 millivolts and 1.7 nanoamps,spiking energy of about 37 picojoules at a typical membrane capacitance, within the range thewith a spiking energy of about 37 picojoules at a typical membrane capacitance, within the range theauthors cite for real neurons.[^fu2025] A Northwestern team instead printed graphene andauthors cite for real neurons.[^fu2025] A Northwestern team instead printed graphene and molybdenummolybdenum disulfide nanosheet inks onto flexible substrates, producing memristive neurons thatdisulfide nanosheet inks onto flexible substrates, producing memristive neurons that fire singlefire single spikes, tonic trains and bursts at frequencies up to 20 kHz.[^hadke2026]spikes, tonic trains and bursts at frequencies up to 20 kHz.[^hadke2026] **Organic electrochemical neurons** are built from transistors whose polymer channel conducts both**Organic electrochemical neurons** are built from transistors whose polymer channel conducts bothions and electrons, so ions in the surrounding fluid alter the firing directly. Linköping Universityions and electrons, so ions in the surrounding fluid alter the firing directly. Researchers atresearchers first made fully printed versions,[^harikesh2022] then built a version whose firing approaches 100 Hz andLinköping University first made fully printed versions,[^harikesh2022] then a version whose firingcan be modulated by sodium, glutamine or neurotransmitters.[^harikesh2023] A Max Planck Instituteapproaches 100 Hz and can be modulated by sodium, glutamine or neurotransmitters.[^harikesh2023] Afor Polymer Research group built a two-transistor organic neuron that operates in liquid and changesMax Planck Institute for Polymer Research group built a two-transistor organic neuron that operatesits excitability in response to dopamine or small shifts in ion concentration; placed behind ain liquid and changes its excitability in response to dopamine or small shifts in ion concentration.layer of intestinal epithelial cells, its firing was suppressed by the layer's barrier to ionPlaced behind a layer of intestinal epithelial cells, its firing was suppressed by the layer'sflow.[^sarkar2022]barrier to ion flow.[^sarkar2022] ## Development history## Development history lines 100–106 → 100–1066 unchanged lines not shown
{ "year": "2020", "title": "Brain and silicon linked online", "text": "Memristive synapses connect a cultured rat neuron in Padova with silicon neurons in Zurich, routed through Southampton over the internet." }, { "year": "2020", "title": "Brain and silicon linked online", "text": "Memristive synapses connect a cultured rat neuron in Padova with silicon neurons in Zurich, routed through Southampton over the internet." }, { "year": "2022", "title": "Organic neurons meet biology", "text": "A printed organic neuron closes a Venus flytrap; another has its firing modulated in real time by a layer of epithelial cells." }, { "year": "2022", "title": "Organic neurons meet biology", "text": "A printed organic neuron closes a Venus flytrap; another has its firing modulated in real time by a layer of epithelial cells." }, { "year": "2023", "title": "Mouse nerve stimulated", "text": "An organic electrochemical neuron that senses ions and glutamine stimulates the vagus nerve of anaesthetized mice and changes heart rate." }, { "year": "2023", "title": "Mouse nerve stimulated", "text": "An organic electrochemical neuron that senses ions and glutamine stimulates the vagus nerve of anaesthetized mice and changes heart rate." }, { "year": "2025–2026", "title": "Biological amplitudes and timescales", "text": "Protein-nanowire neurons match biological voltage and energy; printed MoS2 neurons stimulate Purkinje neurons in mouse cerebellar slices." } { "year": "2025-2026", "title": "Biological amplitudes and timescales", "text": "Protein-nanowire neurons match biological voltage and energy; printed MoS2 neurons stimulate Purkinje neurons in mouse cerebellar slices." }]]`````` lines 109–194 → 109–1952 unchanged lines not shown
Each claimed connection to living tissue is narrower than its headline.Each claimed connection to living tissue is narrower than its headline. **Into tissue.** The printed Northwestern neurons stimulated Purkinje neurons in slices of mouse**Into tissue.** The printed Northwestern neurons stimulated Purkinje neurons in slices of mousecerebellum, work done with Indira Raman's neurobiology laboratory.[^hadke2026] The Linköpingcerebellum, work done with Indira Raman's neurobiology laboratory.[^hadke2026] The Linköping organicorganic neuron, coupled to a nerve cuff, stimulated the right cervical vagus nerve of anaesthetizedneuron, coupled to a nerve cuff, stimulated the right cervical vagus nerve of anaesthetized mice,mice, lowering heart rate by about 4.5%; its authors state explicitly that the demonstration does not amount to alowering heart rate by about 4.5%. Its authors state explicitly that the demonstration does notnew therapy.[^harikesh2023] The earlier printed organic neuron triggered closure of a Venus flytrap,amount to a new therapy.[^harikesh2023] The earlier printed organic neuron triggered closure of aa plant.[^harikesh2022]Venus flytrap, a plant.[^harikesh2022] **Out of tissue.** The UMass neuron processed signals from cardiomyocytes, heart muscle cells**Out of tissue.** The UMass neuron processed signals from cardiomyocytes, heart muscle cellsderived from human embryonic stem cells and grown on a graphene sensor mesh. It stayed silent at thederived from human embryonic stem cells and grown on a graphene sensor mesh. It stayed silent at thetissue's baseline beating rate and fired once noradrenaline raised it, so it distinguished twotissue's baseline beating rate and fired once noradrenaline raised the rate, so it could distinguishphysiological states. The signals passed through an amplifier first, and the cells were heart cellstwo physiological states. The signals passed through an amplifier first, and the cells were heartrather than neurons.[^fu2025]cells rather than neurons.[^fu2025] **Both directions.** The clearest two-way demonstration is a 2020 network in which memristive**Both directions.** The clearest two-way demonstration is a 2020 network in which memristivesynapses linked a single cultured rat hippocampal neuron to silicon spiking neurons, with thesynapses linked a single cultured rat hippocampal neuron to silicon spiking neurons, with theconnection strengthening or weakening according to firing rates. The three sites communicated overconnection strengthening or weakening according to firing rates. The three sites communicated overthe internet, and the biological side was read through a patch-clamp pipette, a method that doesthe internet, and the biological side was read through a patch-clamp pipette, a method that does notnot scale beyond the laboratory bench.[^serb2020] A 2019 system took the same idea toward repair:scale beyond the laboratory bench.[^serb2020] A 2019 system applied the same idea to repair.dissociated neurons were grown as two connected modules, the link between them was cut with aDissociated neurons were grown as two connected modules and the link between them was cut with alaser, and a field-programmable gate array running a spiking network restored bidirectionallaser; a field-programmable gate array running a spiking network then restored bidirectionalactivity between them or stood in for the missing half.[^buccelli2019]activity between the modules or stood in for the missing half.[^buccelli2019] Coverage of the April 2026 Northwestern paper ran under the headline that artificial neuronsCoverage of the April 2026 Northwestern paper ran under the headline that artificial neurons "talk""talk" to real brain cells, "paving way to better brain implants". The same Live Science reportto real brain cells, "paving way to better brain implants". The same Live Science report quotedquoted Timothée Levi, a bioelectronics researcher at the University of Bordeaux who was notTimothée Levi, a bioelectronics researcher at the University of Bordeaux who was not involved, asinvolved, as saying such devices can control living neurons "for a short time but not yet for a longsaying such devices can control living neurons "for a short time but not yet for a long time", andtime", and so are not fit to be permanent additions to a human brain.[^guenot2026]so are not fit to be permanent additions to a human brain.[^guenot2026] > [!caution] What "communicating with brain cells" has meant> [!caution] What "communicating with brain cells" has meant> None of the studies here implanted an artificial neuron chronically in any animal, let alone a> None of the studies here implanted an artificial neuron chronically in any animal, let alone a> person. The brain-tissue results are acute slice and culture experiments, the in vivo result is an> person. The brain-tissue results are acute slice and culture experiments, the in vivo result is an> acute experiment in anaesthetized mice, and several "bio-integration"> acute experiment in anaesthetized mice, and several "bio-integration" demonstrations used heart> demonstrations used heart cells, epithelial membranes or a plant. Durability is also unmeasured at> cells, epithelial membranes or a plant. Durability is also unmeasured at implant scale: the> implant scale: the printed MoS2 neurons were stable for more than a million cycles, which at ten> printed MoS2 neurons were stable for more than a million cycles, which at ten spikes a second is> spikes a second is roughly a day of firing.> roughly a day of firing. ## Limitations## Limitations The hard problems are the ones that limit every chronic [[brain-computer-interface]], plus some ofThe hard problems are the ones that limit every chronic [[brain-computer-interface]], plus some oftheir own. Any implant provokes a foreign-body response that encapsulates electrodes over months, astheir own. Any implant provokes a foreign-body response that encapsulates electrodes over months, asdocumented for the [[utah-array]]; the cited artificial-neuron papers do not report tissuedocumented for the [[utah-array]]. The cited artificial-neuron papers do not report tissue responsesresponses because none was implanted for longer than an acute experiment. Filament formation isbecause none was implanted for longer than an acute experiment. Filament formation is partly random,partly random, so firing varies from device to device and from cycle to cycle. And the coupling itself still runsso firing varies from device to device and from cycle to cycle. The coupling itself still runsthrough conventional electrodes, pipettes or cuffs, so an artificial neuron does not remove thethrough conventional electrodes, pipettes or cuffs, so an artificial neuron leaves the interfaceinterface problem; it changes what sits behind it.problem in place and changes only what sits behind it. A single neuron is also not a circuit. Hersam, the senior Northwestern author, described theA single neuron is also not a circuit. Hersam, the senior Northwestern author, described the"frontier problem" as integrating devices that mimic separate elements of the brain into circuits"frontier problem" as integrating devices that mimic separate elements of the brain into circuitswith full functionality.[^guenot2026] The brain-slice and nerve results each test one device drivingwith full functionality.[^guenot2026] The brain-slice and nerve results each test one device drivingtissue, not a network of artificial neurons maintaining a computation with a network of real ones.tissue. None tests a network of artificial neurons maintaining a computation with a network of realones. ## Risks## Risks Because no device has been implanted, the risks are prospective. They are the risks of anyBecause no device has been implanted, the risks are prospective. They are the risks of anypenetrating neural implant: surgical injury, infection, and the long-term consequence ofpenetrating neural implant: surgical injury, infection, and the long-term consequence of stimulationstimulation that is not identical to natural input, which in [[deep-brain-stimulation]] includesthat is not identical to natural input, which in [[deep-brain-stimulation]] includes mood andmood and behavioural side effects. The UMass design depends on silver filaments forming andbehavioural side effects. The UMass design depends on silver filaments forming and dissolving, anddissolving, and none of the cited studies tests what such materials do in tissue over months. A device thatnone of the cited studies tests what such materials do in tissue over months. A device that adaptsadapts its firing to local chemistry is also harder to audit than a fixed stimulator, which bears onits firing to local chemistry is also harder to audit than a fixed stimulator. That bears on thethe questions raised under [[mental-privacy]] and [[neurorights]] about who can read or alter neuralquestions raised under [[mental-privacy]] and [[neurorights]] about who can read or alter neuralactivity.activity. ## Outlook## Outlook Proponents argue that artificial neurons could make prostheses that speak the nervous system's ownProponents argue that artificial neurons could make prostheses that speak the nervous system's ownlanguage: a [[retinal-implant]] or [[cochlear-implant]] whose output is shaped like natural spikes, alanguage: a [[retinal-implant]] or [[cochlear-implant]] whose output is shaped like natural spikes,[[memory-prosthesis]] that replaces a damaged circuit with a matched one, or a closed-loopa [[memory-prosthesis]] that replaces a damaged circuit with a matched one, or a closed-loopstimulator for the vagus nerve that responds to the body's chemistry. Some, as Live Sciencestimulator for the vagus nerve that responds to the body's chemistry. Some go further, Live Sciencereported, go further and suggest such devices could replace neurons lost in diseases likereported, and suggest such devices could replace neurons lost in diseases like[[alzheimers-disease]].[^guenot2026] None of these has been tested.[[alzheimers-disease]].[^guenot2026] None of these applications has been tested. The nearer competitors are not standing still. Conventional electrodes driven by digitalThe nearer competitors are also advancing. Conventional electrodes driven by digital electronics,electronics, refined by better [[neural-decoding]], already restore function in small numbers ofrefined by better [[neural-decoding]], already restore function in small numbers of people. Inpeople; [[optogenetics]] achieves cell-type specificity in animals; and wireless miniaturization ofanimals, [[optogenetics]] achieves cell-type specificity, and wireless miniaturization of the kindthe kind pursued under [[neural-dust]] attacks the tethering problem directly. A further line usespursued under [[neural-dust]] attacks the tethering problem directly. A further line uses livingliving neurons rather than electronic ones, as in [[organoids]] and biohybrid circuits.neurons rather than electronic ones, as in [[organoids]] and biohybrid circuits. The longest-range claims connect bio-interfacing neurons to piecemeal neuron replacement as a pathThe longest-range claims connect bio-interfacing neurons to piecemeal neuron replacement as a pathtoward [[mind-uploading]] and [[substrate-independence]]. That argument depends on electronictoward [[mind-uploading]] and [[substrate-independence]]. That argument requires electronic neuronsneurons reproducing not just spike timing but plasticity, neuromodulation and the full repertoire ofto reproduce plasticity, neuromodulation and the full repertoire of a cell's chemistry as well asa cell's chemistry, over decades, in place. The experimental record reaches spike timing in a dish.spike timing, over decades, in place. The experimental record so far reaches spike timing in a dish. ## See also## See also removed, struck through added, underlinedLine numbers count the serialised markdown of each revision, frontmatter included.
151 lines are the same in both revisions, and 75 of them are not shown. Neither revision here is necessarily the current article — read Bio-interfacing artificial neurons for the text this wiki stands behind today.