What changed between revision 2 and revision 3, compared over the article's markdown source with its frontmatter — so a change to status, evidence or reversibility shows up as the edit it is.
Older · revision 2
Import
Re-import of content/neuralink.md — the file changed after the initial import. Not an edit.
12.2 kB
Revision 2
Revision 3
lines 6–13 → 6–135 unchanged lines not shown
horizon: "late 2020s"horizon: "late 2020s"categories: ["organizations", "cybernetics"]categories: ["organizations", "cybernetics"]tags: ["bci", "neurotechnology", "implants", "elon musk", "clinical trials", "paralysis"]tags: ["bci", "neurotechnology", "implants", "elon musk", "clinical trials", "paralysis"]summary: "American neurotechnology company founded in 2016 developing a wireless implanted brain–computer interface with flexible electrode threads inserted by a surgical robot."summary: "American neurotechnology company founded in 2016 developing a wireless implanted brain-computer interface with flexible electrode threads inserted by a surgical robot."updated: "2026-07-27"updated: "2026-10-29"issues: ["Series E size and valuation are attributed to the company with no citation.", "Blindsight and CONVOY paragraphs rest on company statements not cited as footnotes."]issues: ["Series E size and valuation are attributed to the company with no citation.", "Blindsight and CONVOY paragraphs rest on company statements not cited as footnotes."]------ lines 33–64 → 33–6419 unchanged lines not shown
The company began implanting the device in humans in January 2024 under an FDA investigationalThe company began implanting the device in humans in January 2024 under an FDA investigationaldevice exemption.device exemption. Neuralink's technical contribution is largely in engineering and surgery rather than neuroscience:Neuralink's technical contribution lies largely in engineering and surgery rather thanflexible electrode threads that move with the brain, automated insertion, high channel counts in aneuroscience: flexible electrode threads that move with the brain, automated insertion, highsealed wireless package, and a hermetic implant with no percutaneous connector. Its scientificchannel counts in a sealed wireless package, and a hermetic implant with no percutaneous connector.results to date have been communicated mainly through livestreams and company blog posts ratherIts scientific results to date have been communicated mainly through livestreams and company blogthan peer-reviewed publication, which is the most common criticism levelled at it by academic BCIposts rather than peer-reviewed publication, the criticism academic BCI researchers most oftenresearchers.level at it. ## Technology## Technology The N1 implant houses a battery, wireless radio, and signal-processing electronics in a packageThe N1 implant houses a battery, wireless radio, and signal-processing electronics in a packagethat sits in a recess milled into the skull, flush with the surrounding bone. From it extend 64that sits in a recess milled into the skull, flush with the surrounding bone. From it extend 64polymer threads bearing 16 electrodes each — 1,024 channels in total — each thread narrower than apolymer threads bearing 16 electrodes each, 1,024 channels in total. Each thread is narrower thanhuman hair and far more compliant than the rigid silicon shanks of a [[utah-array]]. The designa human hair and far more compliant than the rigid silicon shanks of a [[utah-array]]. The designintent is to reduce the micromotion-driven tissue damage that drives glial encapsulation and signalis meant to reduce the micromotion-driven tissue damage that causes glial encapsulation and signalloss in stiff arrays.loss in stiff arrays. Because the threads are too floppy to insert by hand, the R1 robot uses a needle and opticalBecause the threads are too floppy to insert by hand, the R1 robot uses a needle and opticalguidance to place each one individually, steering around surface vasculature. The company describedguidance to place each one individually, steering around surface vasculature. The company describedthe architecture in a 2019 white paper based on rodent work.[^musk2019] Recording, spike detection,the architecture in a 2019 white paper based on rodent work.[^musk2019] Recording, spike detection,and compression happen on the implant; decoded output is sent over Bluetooth to an external device.and compression happen on the implant; decoded output is sent over Bluetooth to an external device.Users control a cursor by attempting or imagining movement, with the mapping learned by a decoderUsers control a cursor by attempting or imagining movement, and a periodically recalibratedthat is periodically recalibrated — the same basic paradigm of [[neural-decoding]] established indecoder learns the mapping. This is the same basic paradigm of [[neural-decoding]] established inacademic laboratories two decades earlier.[^hochberg2006][^gilja2012]academic laboratories two decades earlier.[^hochberg2006][^gilja2012] The device is read-only in its current form. It records but does not stimulate, which places it inThe device is read-only in its current form. It records but does not stimulate, which puts it in aa different category from the implanted neurotechnologies already in routine clinical use, such asdifferent category from the implanted neurotechnologies already in routine clinical use, such asthe [[cochlear-implant]] and [[deep-brain-stimulation]], which write signals in rather thanthe [[cochlear-implant]] and [[deep-brain-stimulation]], which write signals in rather thanreading them out. Adding a stimulation channel is a stated goal and is required for the visualreading them out. Adding a stimulation channel is a stated goal and is required for the visualprogramme, but the safety profile of chronic cortical stimulation is less well characterized thanprogramme, but the safety profile of chronic cortical stimulation is less well characterized thanlines 72–78 → 72–787 unchanged lines not shown
{ "year": "2021", "title": "Macaque cursor control", "text": "A monkey plays a cursor-based video game using the implant, replicating a capability shown in primate laboratories years earlier." }, { "year": "2021", "title": "Macaque cursor control", "text": "A monkey plays a cursor-based video game using the implant, replicating a capability shown in primate laboratories years earlier." }, { "year": "2023", "title": "Human trial cleared", "text": "The FDA grants an investigational device exemption; the PRIME study opens recruitment for people with quadriplegia." }, { "year": "2023", "title": "Human trial cleared", "text": "The FDA grants an investigational device exemption; the PRIME study opens recruitment for people with quadriplegia." }, { "year": "2024", "title": "First human implants", "text": "The first participant receives the device in January; the company later discloses that many threads retracted from the cortex, and modifies its technique for subsequent surgeries." }, { "year": "2024", "title": "First human implants", "text": "The first participant receives the device in January; the company later discloses that many threads retracted from the cortex, and modifies its technique for subsequent surgeries." }, { "year": "2024–2026", "title": "International expansion", "text": "Regulators in Canada, the United Kingdom, and the United Arab Emirates permit studies; the company reports additional participants and a robotic-arm extension study." } { "year": "2024-2026", "title": "International expansion", "text": "Regulators in Canada, the United Kingdom, and the United Arab Emirates permit studies; the company reports additional participants and a robotic-arm extension study." }]]`````` lines 88–95 → 88–959 unchanged lines not shown
several months later and reported recovering performance through changes to signal processing andseveral months later and reported recovering performance through changes to signal processing anddecoding rather than reimplantation.[^nlink2024] For the second participant the company said itdecoding rather than reimplantation.[^nlink2024] For the second participant the company said italtered its technique, sculpting the skull surface to reduce the gap under the implant andaltered its technique, sculpting the skull surface to reduce the gap under the implant andinserting threads deeper. Thread retraction is a specific instance of the general problem thatinserting threads deeper. Thread retraction is one instance of a general problem for everyafflicts every penetrating array: the brain moves, pulses, and reacts to foreign material.penetrating array, which is that the brain moves, pulses, and reacts to foreign material. A companion study, CONVOY, extends control from a cursor to an assistive robotic arm, moving theA companion study, CONVOY, extends control from a cursor to an assistive robotic arm, moving thedevice from computer access toward the broader ambitions of [[neuroprosthetics]]. The company hasdevice from computer access toward the broader ambitions of [[neuroprosthetics]]. The company haslines 98–104 → 98–1042 unchanged lines not shown
programme, Blindsight, aims to restore a crude visual percept by stimulating visual cortex directly;programme, Blindsight, aims to restore a crude visual percept by stimulating visual cortex directly;it received an FDA breakthrough device designation in 2024 but had no published human results as ofit received an FDA breakthrough device designation in 2024 but had no published human results as ofearly 2026. Cortical visual prostheses have a long and largely disappointing history, and theearly 2026. Cortical visual prostheses have a long and largely disappointing history, and theresolution limits that constrained earlier efforts — described under [[retinal-implant]] — applyresolution limits that constrained earlier efforts, described under [[retinal-implant]], applywith equal force here.with equal force here. > [!caution] Company reporting, not trial reporting> [!caution] Company reporting, not trial reportinglines 112–119 → 112–1197 unchanged lines not shown
Neuralink is funded by venture capital and by Musk personally. It raised a Series E in 2025 thatNeuralink is funded by venture capital and by Musk personally. It raised a Series E in 2025 thatthe company said totalled several hundred million dollars at a valuation in the billions, a figurethe company said totalled several hundred million dollars at a valuation in the billions, a figurefar above what any BCI company has justified on revenue, since none has an approved product. Thefar above what any BCI company has justified on revenue, since none has an approved product. Thecapital advantage is real: implant development, robot engineering, animal work, and multi-countrycapital advantage is real. Implant development, robot engineering, animal work, and multi-countryregulatory submissions are expensive in a way academic consortia such as BrainGate cannot match.regulatory submissions cost more than academic consortia such as BrainGate can spend. The founding team has largely dispersed. Several co-founders left within the first few years, andThe founding team has largely dispersed. Several co-founders left within the first few years, andone went on to co-found Precision Neuroscience, which pursues a thin-film surface approach closerone went on to co-found Precision Neuroscience, which pursues a thin-film surface approach closerlines 126–137 → 126–1376 unchanged lines not shown
Assessments divide along a consistent line. Engineers credit the company with solving practicalAssessments divide along a consistent line. Engineers credit the company with solving practicalproblems the field had left unsolved: a fully implanted wireless device with no skull-mountedproblems the field had left unsolved: a fully implanted wireless device with no skull-mountedpedestal, an insertion robot that makes hundreds of precise placements, and a manufacturing processpedestal, an insertion robot that makes hundreds of precise placements, and a manufacturing processfor polymer electrode arrays. Those are the bottlenecks between a laboratory demonstration and afor polymer electrode arrays. Those problems stand between a laboratory demonstration and aproduct.product. Neuroscientists are more sceptical of the framing. The cursor control demonstrated in 2024 wasNeuroscientists are more sceptical of the framing. The cursor control demonstrated in 2024 wasqualitatively similar to results published from academic implants more than a decade earlier, andqualitatively similar to results published from academic implants more than a decade earlier, andthe product name "Telepathy" describes typing with a decoder, not thought transmission — anthe product name "Telepathy" describes typing with a decoder rather than thought transmission, anoverstatement of the kind examined under [[brain-to-brain-interface]]. Claims that the device willoverstatement of the kind examined under [[brain-to-brain-interface]]. Claims that the device willone day enable symbiosis with artificial intelligence, discussed as [[human-ai-merger]], areone day enable symbiosis with artificial intelligence, discussed as [[human-ai-merger]], areuntested and rest on a bandwidth argument that the low-dimensional structure of cortical activityuntested and rest on a bandwidth argument that the low-dimensional structure of cortical activitylines 144–164 → 144–1656 unchanged lines not shown
Neuralink has denied wrongdoing and published its own account of its animal-care programme.Neuralink has denied wrongdoing and published its own account of its animal-care programme. A third strand of criticism concerns data. A device that streams cortical activity to a phoneA third strand of criticism concerns data. A device that streams cortical activity to a phonecreates a record of neural signals held by a private company, raising the questions taken up undercreates a record of neural signals held by a private company, which raises the questions taken up[[mental-privacy]] — not because a cursor decoder reads thoughts, but because the underlyingunder [[mental-privacy]]. A cursor decoder does not read thoughts, but the underlying recordingsrecordings support inferences the user never intended to make available.support inferences the user never intended to make available. ## Outlook## Outlook The questions that will determine whether Neuralink matters are unglamorous. Do threads stay putThe questions that will determine whether Neuralink matters are practical ones: whether threadsover five years? What fraction of participants develop infection or require explant? Can a decoderstay put over five years, what fraction of participants develop infection or require explant,run for weeks without a technician? Does the device work in a home, unsupervised, on a bad day? Thewhether a decoder can run for weeks without a technician, and whether the device works in a home,company's willingness to run multi-country studies suggests a push toward a pivotal trial, but nounsupervised, on a bad day. The company's willingness to run multi-country studies suggests a pushimplanted BCI from any developer has yet been approved for routine clinical use, and the regulatorytoward a pivotal trial, but no implanted BCI from any developer has yet been approved for routinepath for a permanent cortical implant in a non-fatal condition has no precedent to follow.clinical use, and the regulatory path for a permanent cortical implant in a non-fatal condition hasno precedent to follow. A separate question is what happens if the company stops. Implanted devices create obligations thatA separate question is what happens if the company stops. Implanted devices create obligations thatoutlast product lines, an issue that the emerging [[neurorights]] frameworks have begun to name butoutlast product lines, an issue the emerging [[neurorights]] frameworks have begun to name but havenot yet resolved.not yet resolved. ## See also## See alsoremoved, struck through added, underlinedLine numbers count the serialised markdown of each revision, frontmatter included.
153 lines are the same in both revisions, and 83 of them are not shown. Neither revision here is necessarily the current article — read Neuralink for the text this wiki stands behind today.